The Mary Ann Vs. Ginger Debate: Why Does Dawn Wells Always Win?

By | January 2, 2018

test article image
Dawn Wells as Mary Ann on 'Gilligan's Island' (1964-67). Source: IMDB, Wikimedia Commons

Even a half-century after Gilligan’s Island aired its final episode, Dawn Wells remained better known as Mary Ann Summers, one of the seven castaways on the show. Wells, who died on December 30, 2020, was a fan favorite, winning the hearts of viewers with down-home charm in direct contrast to the "sexy" movie star Ginger Grant, played by Tina Louise. Rounding out the cast were Bob Denver (Gilligan), Alan Hale Jr. (Skipper), Russell Johnson (Professor), Jim Backus and Natalie Schafer (the Howells). 

For fans of the beloved show, the question of whether you were drawn to Ginger or Mary Ann was an essential one. And though Ginger was conceived as the breathy sex symbol, the popularity of Dawn Wells as Mary Ann Summers proved that a lot of Americans prefer the humble charm of the girl next door.

In fact, it's not just a lot of viewers who prefer Mary Ann -- it's most of them. In poll after poll online, you'll find Mary Ann besting Ginger as the more appealing of the two unattached lady castaways, often by a wide margin.

Both actresses were beautiful -- but Mary Ann always wins. Why is that?

Seven Castaways. Three Single Men And Two Single Women. What Happens?

test article image

As the story went, the S.S. Minnow was a tour boat that capsized in an unexpected storm. What happened next would be a tale of their survival on the uncharted island where they ended up.

Each cast member had a backstory. Of course, the Skipper and Gilligan were the captain and first mate of the Minnow, and the passengers included Mr. and Mrs. Howell, the Professor, Ginger and Mary Ann. There they were marooned on an island and it would appear that they had left their carnal desires behind when they left civilization.

The Howells were married so they had each other. That left five other people consisting of three men and two women, leaving a dilemma. The men played up to Ginger for obvious reasons. She was a beautiful actress who had legs all the way up to her backside. Then there was sweet, innocent Mary Ann. They could not have been more opposite.